Loading
  • Why register?
  • Register
  • Login
Subscribe to our Newsletter!
  • Shopping Cart Shopping Cart
    0Shopping Cart
PostdocInUSA
  • Welcome
  • Articles
    • Postdocs in USA
      • Postdoc and numbers
      • Postdoc Salary in USA
    • Find a postdoc in USA
      • Apply to postdoc job offers
      • Apply to postdoc fellowships
      • Master your postdoc interview
      • 35 questions to ask during postdoctoral job Interview
    • Postdoc Interview Series
      • Postdoc Interviews
        • Israeli postdoc in Berkeley
        • Italian postdoc in New York
        • German postdoc in San Diego
        • Belgian postdoc in San Francisco
        • Indian postdoc in Denver
        • Pakistani postdoc in Oklahoma City
    • J-1 Visa
      • Apply for a J-1 visa
      • Extend your stay in USA
      • J-1 visa requirements
    • Other
      • Social Security Number
  • Shop
    • Shop All
    • Home Decor
      • Lamps
      • Wall Art
    • Jewelry
      • Bracelets
      • Earrings
      • Rings
      • Necklaces
    • Lanyards
  • Postdoc Jobs
    • For Candidates
      • Search Postdoc Jobs
      • Submit Resume
      • Restricted content
    • For Employers
      • Post a Postdoc Job
      • Browse Postdoc Candidates
    • Pricing
      • Postdoc Job Packages
      • Targeted Postdoc Recruitment Campaign
      • Employer Branding
  • Forum
  • Contact
  • About
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
  • Link to Mail
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • Link to Youtube

myIDP: Applying your self-assessment results to career decision-making

November 20, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

From ScienceMag:

This is the fifth article in a series designed to help you create an Individual Development Plan (IDP) using myIDP, a web-based career-planning tool created to help graduate students and postdocs in the sciences define and pursue their career goals. To learn more about myIDP and begin the career exploration and planning process, please visit myidp.sciencecareers.org.
This is an updated version of an article originally published in 2013.

By now, we hope you have worked through some of the myIDP tool, and you might be wondering, “I’ve compiled a lot of really interesting self-assessment information about my skills, my interests, and my values … but how will these data be useful to me?” The purpose of this article is to help you begin to use your self-assessment information to consider which of your many career options might provide the best fit.

This step of the myIDP process is intended to narrow your career options to the one or two choices that align best with your unique sets of skills and interests and that satisfy your work-related values. These options are likely to provide the most satisfying and rewarding careers for you over the long term. Subsequent articles in this series will discuss ways of positioning yourself for success in these careers.

Why spend time considering skills and interests?

It’s almost certain that you’ve been using your skills and interests for years to make career decisions, even if you haven’t done so consciously. It’s likely that you decided to pursue a Ph.D., for example, because you found your science classes engaging (interests) and performed well in them (skills). Probably, you tried research during college and learned that you liked it (interests) and were good at it (skills). So, the pursuit of a research-based Ph.D. seemed like the logical next step for someone who enjoys research and excels at it. See? You’ve been through this process before, though perhaps not systematically.

Unfortunately, the process is about to get harder because you now need to make decisions about career paths you may not know much about. How much did those early experiences in science teach you about the daily work of an academic researcher? Not much, probably. When you decided to pursue a Ph.D., were you envisioning spending your days writing grants and papers, managing people and resources, driving scientific agendas for your team, and delivering presentations at journal clubs and international conferences? More likely, you were thinking of days spent in the lab or in the field pursuing important scientific questions.

And what about all those other science-related jobs? What’s it like to be a research administrator or to work in regulatory affairs?

These are important questions—and it’s important to get the answers right. Dissatisfaction may arise if you perform tasks that don’t interest you day after day, or if you don’t have opportunities to do the tasks you most enjoy on a daily basis. And without the right complement of skills, you may not be able to land the job you want—and even if you do, you may not perform up to expectations, which could lead to conflict, unhappiness, and failure.

Values: Even more important than skills and interests?

In order to be satisfied, your values must be aligned with your career choice. Your skills and interests could be a perfect match for each other—but if the job you have trained for does not provide the tangible outcomes you want or need the most (earnings level, time freedom, geographic location, and so on) or the intrinsic rewards you seek (prestige, the satisfaction of being an expert, the rush of discovery, the feeling that you are making a difference, and so forth) then you will not be happy in your career.

Using skills, interests, and values to narrow your career options

Here, we offer a step-by-step process to help you identify career options that involve tasks that you are good at and enjoy doing while also providing the rewards and outcomes you need.

  • We’re assuming that you’ve already signed up for myIDP and carefully rated your skills, interests, and values. If you haven’t, please do so now. (For guidance, read: Skills, Interests, Values. Take your time and do it carefully. We can wait.)
  • After you’ve completed your Skills, Interests, and Values assessments, click on the Consider Career Fit section and check out the interesting information under the My Career Path Matches tab. You will see a list of 20 career path categories commonly available to scientists with Ph.D.-level training. The list of career path categories will be presented in a rank order based on your unique responses to the “skills” and “interests” inventories. (If you haven’t completed those inventories, your choices won’t be properly ranked.)
  • How should I interpret the ranking in My Career Path Matches? These are merely well-informed suggestions; just because the career path you’re most interested in ranks 12th or 15th, that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t consider it. The whole point of this exercise—the steps you’re going through right now—is to think this through for yourself and consider on your own—independent of the myIDP recommendations—which career paths seem most appropriate for you.
  • How does myIDP come up with your unique ranking of the career paths? To rank-order this list of career options, we consulted professional career advisors who have extensive experience in scientific careers. These advisors assigned ratings to each skill and interest as they relate to each of myIDP’s 20 career path categories, then we worked with statisticians to write a matching algorithm to calculate your unique skills- and interests-based matches. If you’re interested in learning more about how your responses compare to those of the career advisors, click on the percentage numbers under the “Skills Match” and “Interests Match” columns on the My Career Path Matches page.
  • Next, you can learn more about your career path matches by systematically reading through the list of resources provided for each career path (in myIDP’s “Read About Careers” section), focusing first on either the career paths at the top of the list or the ones you’re most interested in.
    • Interests: As you read, identify the options that involve a high proportion of tasks that you find engaging and enjoyable, and a low proportion of tasks you find boring and unpleasant. You may find it helpful to return to your lists of interests and review (and maybe even revise) your answers.
    • Skills: After you’ve identified careers that seem like a good match for your interests, identify those that involve a high proportion of tasks that you are good at doing—your skills—and a low proportion of tasks where you need a lot of improvement, or that you may never be good at. But keep in mind: You’ve spent years acquiring new skills, and you’re capable of doing it again—and again. So, while it’s important to choose careers that match your (current) interests and values, it’s up to you to decide how much additional time and effort to put in in order to acquire new skills. This means that you don’t have to rule out a career just because you don’t have the skills for it. You can probably learn the skills you need if you’re willing to put in the effort.
    • Values: Finally, learn as much as you can about your pared-down list of career options so that you can identify those that are a good match for your values. As you read, guard against preconceived ideas about the various career-path options, which might lead to an incorrect judgment about how well a career category will truly fit your skills, interests, and values. (“I heard that all management consultants travel 100% of the time”; “My principal investigator told me that industry scientists have no intellectual freedom.”) Instead, keep an open mind and study each path before you decide if it would be a good fit for you.

    You may wish to go beyond the resources we have provided by consulting books and other Web-based resources. For example, industry-specific salary tables might help you determine whether a path is likely to fulfill your income goals.

    Finally, don’t only read about your career options. Go out and talk to people about the career paths you’re most interested in. Network and conduct informational interviews with people in the field, or at a specific company of interest to you. One-on-one conversations can help you learn more about workplace climate and family-friendly policies, for example.

    Remind yourself why you’re doing this!

    The diagram below illustrates the overall goal of these exercises: To find that small subset of all the possible career options that will engage you in the most interesting tasks, take advantage of your best skills, and provide the rewards you most need from your career. Working through the six steps above may require a lot of time and effort, but we promise it will be worth it!

    A Venn diagram showing career satisfaction at the intersection of skills, values, and interests.

    Acknowledgements

    The authors wish to thank the people below for their input in the development of the career-matching component of myIDP. These professionals, who specialize in careers for Ph.D.-level scientists, completed extensive surveys regarding the required skills and common tasks of each career path in myIDP. These data formed the basis of the career matching calculation in the Career Exploration section of myIDP. Their names are listed alongside their employer at the time they contributed to this project.

    Michael Alvarez, MD Anderson Cancer Center
    Jim Austin, AAAS ScienceCareers.org
    Lisa Balbes, Author, Nontraditional Careers for Chemists
    Lori Conlan, NIH Office of Intramural Training and Education
    Teresa Dillinger, University of California, Davis
    Stephanie Eberle, Stanford University
    Toby Freedman, Author, Career Opportunities in Biotechnology and Drug Development
    Dara Grant, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
    Briana Keller, University of Washington, Seattle
    John Lombardo, Medical College of Wisconsin
    Kim Petrie, Vanderbilt University
    Melanie Sinche, Harvard University
    Lydia Soleil, Georgia Gwinnett College
    Molly Starback, Duke University
    Joe Tringali, Tringali and Associates
    Ryan Wheeler, The Scripps Research Institute

    The authors also wish to thank H. Garrison, J. Boscardin, and M. Clifford for helpful discussions of statistical analyses required for the career matching calculation. J. Boscardin’s time was in part supported by the National Center for Research Resources and the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences, National Institutes of Health (NIH), through UCSF-CTSI Grant Number UL1 RR024131. The contents of this project are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of NIH.

    Read More

    http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png 0 0 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-20 12:46:302026-11-20 12:46:30myIDP: Applying your self-assessment results to career decision-making

    myIDP: Interests

    November 20, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    This is the third article in a series designed to help you create an Individual Development Plan (IDP) using myIDP, a web-based career-planning tool created to help graduate students and postdocs in the sciences define and pursue their career goals. To learn more about myIDP and begin the career exploration and planning process, please visit myidp.sciencecareers.org.
    This is an updated version of an article originally published in 2012.

    As he finished up an important paper from his postdoc, Kai, a cancer biologist, began to think about the next steps he would need to take as he moved on in his career. Kai felt confident that his day-to-day, research-related skills were solid; he was really good at many tasks required for success in a future research career. At the same time, he was beginning to recognize that some of those tasks he was good at doing were not tasks that he enjoyed. 

    In the myIDP tool, we refer to career-related “interests” as the everyday tasks that you enjoy doing in a job (or do not enjoy doing). For Kai, who was struggling to figure out what to do next in his career, he knew it would be important to make a list of those tasks he found engaging and those he found to be drudgery, so he completed the myIDP Interests Assessment.

    People had always told Kai that he was a skilled and dynamic presenter—and because he had been the only cell biologist in his postdoc lab, he had become adept at explaining complex scientific concepts clearly to a broad array of scientists. Furthermore, he enjoyed these activities above all the other things he did in the course of a workday. So, clustered at the top of his myIDP list of most favored Interests were “giving presentations about science” and “teaching in a classroom setting.”

    Yet, Kai was not so enthusiastic about written scientific communications: Despite being an excellent writer, he found writing papers and proposals unpleasant—indeed, in his myIDP Interests assessment, he noted that these were listed among his least favorite tasks.

    Kai had long thought of academia as his default career path. There were things about the career path that he liked. Most academic scientists teach, and he was up for that: He was sure he would be a great teacher. Most academic scientists present their work at conferences, and he was up for that, too. But principal investigators (PIs), he realized, also spend a lot of time writing grant proposals and scientific articles. Because he did not enjoy writing-related tasks, he began to think he might struggle to find the motivation to produce the grant proposals and scientific articles that he would need to succeed.

    So Kai began to develop a list of careers that would emphasize his interest in presenting and educating, while minimizing the writing tasks he most disliked. He explored teaching-focused faculty posts (these, too, he learned, typically involve writing papers and grant proposals, though not as much), running science-outreach programs (ditto on the grant proposals), business development, and management consulting. In the end, he decided to pursue a position as a medical science liaison (MSL). After some additional exploration, a lot of networking, and a job search that was, frankly, a little longer than he expected, Kai was hired to represent a class of cancer drugs for a major pharmaceutical company.

    It was a great fit. As an MSL, he spent most of his time synthesizing information from drug studies and preparing and delivering symposia and seminars to physicians, researchers, and medical societies. Occasionally, he presented to patient groups.

    Professional interests

    Kai’s story is a great example of how career-related interests can influence job satisfaction, and how thinking hard about those interests can shorten the path between scientific training and a fulfilling career. A careful and detailed analysis of “interests” is at the core of the assessment phase in myIDP.

    Your top interests are, in myIDP terms, the work tasks you find appealing enough to do frequently when you are given a choice. Before you go very far in choosing your career, it’s a good idea to identify those tasks. Equally important is knowing which tasks you least enjoy doing, the ones that would make you miserable if you had to perform them frequently.

    No job is perfect. Every job involves tasks that are boring, distracting, or onerous. But as you analyze any possible career path, you need to break it down to the day-to-day tasks required for success in that position and then think about how those tasks match your own list of most-favorite and least-favorite tasks. If you can find a career option that lets you perform a lot of the most engaging tasks while mostly avoiding tasks that you dislike, then you’ve found an option worth exploring. If you enjoy the day-to-day work, you’ll look forward to performing the work, you’ll be more energized and prouder of what you accomplish, and—very likely—you’ll ultimately be more successful.

    Using myIDP to assess your interests

    myIDP includes an interests assessment tool that will help you rank many of the tasks scientists perform, from those that you enjoy most to those you enjoy least. (You’ll find the interests assessment tool here, though we recommend working through myIDP systematically, from the beginning.) This confidential self-assessment tool asks you to rate how engaging you find each of 39 tasks on a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 means “I would never like to do this in my career” and 5 is “I would like to do this often in my career.” The assessment will be most helpful if you use the full range of scores—that is, don’t cluster your scores around the middle.

    What if your skills and interests don’t align?

    In a previous article, we described the myIDP skills assessment tool. If you haven’t already carried out that part of myIDP, feel free to go do it now—just make sure you’ve got enough time to think hard and choose carefully.

    Upon assessing their skills and their interests, some people find that they don’t align. What should you do then?

    It’s natural to want a career that requires you to perform tasks you are skilled at performing. But if you find yourself in a career that involves tasks you are good at performing but don’t enjoy, then you’re likely to become dissatisfied sooner or later. Kai doesn’t enjoy writing, so he avoided jobs that would require him to prepare manuscripts, grant proposals, or written business proposals.

    It can be tempting to believe that things will change, that you can learn to like—or at least tolerate—those parts of your job that you currently dislike. In some cases, you may find you need to pursue or remain in such a position due to personal, economic, or other reasons. Or you may feel that you should because you have already invested time, money, and/or effort in developing a certain skill set—a feeling of reluctance referred to by economists as the sunk cost fallacy. For example, maybe you’re still in academia, but, unlike Kai, the thought of teaching keeps you up at night. Still, maybe someday you’ll learn to love classroom teaching. It happens. But in our collective experience, when possible, it’s a better bet to pursue a career that lets you do the things you like to do. Interests do change over time, especially as you become more skilled at performing those tasks, but forcing yourself to do something that makes you miserable, day after day, isn’t the best way to make that happen.

    Likewise, you may find yourself pursuing a career that requires you to perform tasks you enjoy but requires skills that you are weak in. In this case, you probably should make a plan to develop those skills so that you can continue along a path you so enjoy.

    Check your assumptions

    As you consider how job roles align with your skills and interests, be careful not to make key decisions based solely on your own assumptions. For example, you may be thinking about stepping away from the research PI career path for which you have been training for so many years. Be sure you can identify exactly what you think will be dissatisfying about a career as a PI. If it’s an interests-related issue—that is, if you don’t like the tasks you believe are critical for success as a PI—then be sure to check that your assumptions are correct. If it’s a skills-related issue—that is, if you feel you aren’t good enough at some tasks to succeed as a PI—ask yourself, “Realistically, can I improve on that skill sufficiently to succeed as a PI?” Ask trusted mentors to provide feedback on your abilities in this area.

    Choosing or changing a career path is a big undertaking. Making sure you enjoy a job’s daily tasks should play a major role in that decision. In this respect, as in all others, myIDP aims to reduce the anxiety from the process of choosing a career and help you make rational, well-informed choices. Ultimately, career decisions are yours, and only you will know how to best factor your skills and interests into choices about your future career. Be intentional about gathering information and feedback to help inform these decisions. The goal, of course, is a career you find rewarding.

    Read More

    http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png 0 0 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-20 12:46:292026-11-20 12:46:29myIDP: Interests

    myIDP: What do you care about?

    November 20, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    This is the fourth article in a series designed to help you create an Individual Development Plan (IDP) using myIDP, a web-based career-planning tool created to help graduate students and postdocs in the sciences define and pursue their career goals. To learn more about myIDP and begin the career exploration and planning process, please visit myidp.sciencecareers.org.
    This is an updated version of an article originally published in 2012.

    Mira and her husband John, both postdocs, were feeling squeezed. They wanted to start a family soon, and they were worried that they would not have enough money to live comfortably with children in the region where they lived.

    So Mira was intrigued when a sales rep visiting her lab told her about an open field applications scientist position at his company (a major microscope vendor), and mentioned that in a position like that, she could double her current salary. Mira applied for the job, interviewed, and got the offer. Her husband was enthusiastic about the opportunity. She was about to sign on the dotted line—and then she began to have second thoughts. She began to ask herself questions such as:

    • Sure, the money would be nice, but how will I balance childcare with the extensive travel that the job requires?
    • What first attracted me to this field applications position was a desire to make more money. But I chose biomedical research because my most important work-related values included a desire to have an impact on my field, work on cutting-edge medical questions, and make a real difference in people’s lives. Will I be able to realize those goals in the new position?
    • Money is important, but do I want to work that many hours, away from my family?

    Worrying that she wouldn’t find this position satisfying, Mira asked the company for extra time to consider her decision.

    Work-related values and job satisfaction

    It is self-evident that job satisfaction is affected by how well the job matches up with the worker’s values. Like many workers, Mira’s work-related values include the potential to earn a larger salary and the opportunity to work regular hours that allow her to be with her family. But as mentioned above, other aspects of work that Mira values are less tangible, including the feeling that she is helping others and the sense of daily excitement that comes from working on the frontiers of knowledge. (Here and elsewhere in the article, italics designate particular work-related values listed on myIDP.)

    Mira’s story illustrates how a scientist might experience such a connection between values and work-related satisfaction (or dissatisfaction): She identified current and future salary—what myIDP labels earning potential—as a work-related value, and her low earnings in her current job contributed to her dissatisfaction. This value was important enough to her—and her current salary far enough below what she desired—that she was motivated to alter (or at least consider altering) the course of her career.

    Mira’s story illustrates two aspects of work-related values:

    • Values need to be prioritized when choosing a career. There are trade-offs among values when considering a career path, and you must often weigh some values against others. For a while, earning potential dominated Mira’s thinking—probably because it was her current job’s most obvious shortcoming. But just as she considered making a big change, she became aware that remuneration was not the attribute she valued most highly. She began to question whether she was willing to sacrifice time with family to achieve a higher salary.
    • Work-related values change with stages of life. When they moved to their city after finishing graduate school, Mira and John were younger and more carefree. Money didn’t matter as much. But as they began to think about raising children in an expensive city, money became a higher priority—though not, perhaps, the highest. Mira’s work-related values will continue to change as time passes and her circumstances change. Years from now, when her children are in school, perhaps an attractive position that requires a lot of travel might seem like less of a disadvantage.

    What did Mira decide? Her need to have time for her future family, and to continue to contribute to her scientific field, outweighed the earnings potential of the field applications position. She turned down the job—and kept looking for others that would pay more than she was getting as a postdoc but that would also be consistent with the rest of her work-related values.*

    How can I evaluate my own work-related values?

    Mira’s story illustrates how important it is to clarify and prioritize work-related values—but she could have saved herself some trouble if she had gone about it in a more organized way!

    That’s what myIDP is for. It includes a values assessment tool to help you identify, clarify, and prioritize your work-related values. You’ll be presented with a list of common work-related values and asked to rate the importance of each one, from 1 (unimportant) to 5 (essential). As we wrote before on the topics of skills and interests, this works best when you spread your scores: Don’t cluster all of your answers around 3. And try to be discriminating so that you don’t have more than about five 5s. (It’s difficult to make career decisions if everything is important to you!)

    If you haven’t already done it, now is a good time to complete the myIDP values assessment tool. If you’ve done it already, visit myIDP and take a few minutes to review your responses. Then come back to this article and read the following section.

    Understanding your values assessment

    As you work through your values, new questions may arise. Common questions are:

    Q: Prioritizing is hard! All of my highly scored values feel very important. How can I be sure that I ranked my top five priorities correctly?

    A: Look at your list of top priorities and ask yourself:

    • What are your absolute must-have values, without which you would absolutely turn down a job offer?
    • If you were forced to give up one or more of your most highly ranked values, which would be the first to go? Which would be the second?

    Q: How can I be sure I’m being honest with myself?

    A: Excellent question. Sometimes what we really want isn’t what we think we want, or what we think we ought to want. Go back and look at your list of prioritized values one more time. Ask yourself: Did you place a high priority on any of those values because you thought they should be important to you—but really, they’re not? Are some values assigned a low priority because you don’t think they should be important to you—but in fact they are? Some scientists may feel inclined to list “helping society” as a top value when what they find most rewarding is the process of finding the answers to thorny questions, no matter how esoteric. (If that describes your values, intellectual challenge, work on the frontiers of knowledge, and perhaps creativity should rank high on your myIDP values list.). Because academic science reinforces a culture of self-sacrifice, it is not uncommon for scientists to be reluctant to admit that they value recognition, status and prestige, or earning potential. But if you make career choices based on what you should value instead of what you actually value, you’re likely to end up miserable.

    As you consider how well a job matches up with your values, consider this: No job will match up with your values perfectly, and that’s okay. Some of your values, such as help society, can be met via activities you engage in outside of work.

    Q: How do I determine if a particular career is a good match for my values?

    A: As you learn about career options, think about how the work-related values you rated as most important might align or disconnect with each career option. Even in the same job or role, different work environments might or might not provide an alignment with your values, so we recommend talking to multiple people employed in career paths you are considering. For example, before Mira was applying to positions, she could have made a list of questions based on her prioritized list of values—help others; earning potential; work on frontiers of knowledge—and explored these in informational interviews with several people already working as field applications scientists. Using this insider knowledge might have helped her identify aspects of the job that were a poor fit for her—before she started the job search process.

    Within myIDP, we’ve provided a customized list of possible questions that you should ask yourself based on your unique set of prioritized values. If you find that you don’t know the answers, this is a great starting point for designing questions for those informational interviews. To view the list, click on “Consider Your Values!” on the page titled “Consider Career Fit/My Career Path Matches.”

    No career will make you 100% happy 100% of the time. However, by utilizing tools like myIDP, you should be able to increase the confidence with which you make work-related choices and improve your chances of ending up in a deeply satisfying career.

    *Mira, who is based on a real scientist, decided not to become a field applications scientist, and for her it was the right decision. But for many others, this interesting, useful, and potentially lucrative career path would be an ideal match.

    Read More

    http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png 0 0 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-20 12:46:292026-11-20 12:46:29myIDP: What do you care about?

    myIDP: Successful scientists need both technical and professional skills

    November 20, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    This is the second article in a series designed to help you create an Individual Development Plan (IDP) using myIDP, a web-based career-planning tool created to help graduate students and postdocs in the sciences define and pursue their career goals. To learn more about myIDP and begin the career exploration and planning process, please visit myidp.sciencecareers.org.
    This is an updated version of an article originally published in 2012.

    You have been expending a tremendous amount of effort in building the research and technical skills that are necessary for success in research. You may not have given much thought to other skills that you will need for a productive and satisfying career. The importance of professional skills is often underappreciated despite the fact that numerous professional organizations have emphasized the value of professional skills for Ph.D. scientists. 

    The National Institute of General Medical Sciences highlighted the range of skills needed to be a great scientist—from methods, technology, and quantitative skills to leadership, management, communication, and teamwork1. In their publication Graduate STEM Education for the 21st Century, the National Academy of Sciences called for training Ph.D. scientists in professional competencies like leadership, communication, and project management2. Likewise, a conference on the future of graduate and postdoctoral training in the biosciences advocating modernization of Ph.D. curricula to include skills in communication, teamwork and collaboration, leadership and development, and project management3. It is noteworthy that job postings by biotech employers also emphasize these skills.4 To help visualize a balance of research skills with professional skills, the construct of T-shaped professionals may be useful (Figure 1)5.  

    To help visualize a balance of research skills with professional skills, the construct of T-shaped professionals may be useful

    Successful Ph.D. scientists need deep knowledge in their area of disciplinary specialization as well as a breadth of professional skills.

    Taking stock of your skills

    The first step in honing your skill set is figuring out what you’re good at and what needs to be improved. While this may seem obvious, few of us really take the time to reflect on this. The myIDP skills assessment was designed to do just that. Created specifically for scientists, this assessment includes the knowledge, skills, and abilities that are important for success in research training as well as across a breadth of scientific careers. It is also designed to help scientists evaluate their competence in areas that may not have been a formal part of doctoral science training but are fundamental to obtaining—and keeping—science-related jobs. Adapted from the National Postdoctoral Association’s The NPA Postdoctoral Core Competencies6, the myIDP skills assessment has seven categories: scientific knowledge, research skills, communication, leadership and management, professionalism, responsible conduct of research, and career development. These skill areas are described in more detail below.

    Scientific knowledge

    To succeed in any discipline, you need to have the content knowledge. For scientists, this means having both a broad–based knowledge of science and a deep knowledge of their specific research area. Of course, science is dynamic; the knowledge base is changing daily as researchers collect more and more data. To be competitive, therefore, you should be able to critically evaluate the scientific literature, integrate new information about your field into your existing knowledge base, and identify gaps in the research that are ripe for new investigation.

    Research skills

    Whether you work at the bench or in the field, you must have the research and technical skills required to execute your studies. Over the course of your doctoral training, you should become increasingly proficient in study design, conducting the appropriate statistical analyses of your data, and interpreting the results. Throughout your scientific career, you’ll face intellectual and technical challenges that will call upon your ability to think creatively and propose innovative solutions to the problems you face, skills that will likely improve with practice. Publications are the coin of the realm in science, so, in addition to doing great work, you have to publish it. You should become familiar with the publishing standards in your discipline, acquire practice writing and submitting papers for publication, and take advantage of opportunities to serve as a reviewer.

    Communication

    By the time you get to graduate school, you should have mastered basic writing, editing, speaking, and presentation skills; if you haven’t, this should be a major focus of your skills development, as communication skills are highly valued in all careers. If you’re pursuing a research career, you should aim for expertise in writing scientific publications and grant proposals and giving technical talks and poster presentations. These skills are less important outside of research, but you’ll still need to be at least moderately proficient in these areas to complete graduate and postdoctoral work and to compete for some research administration roles.

    Communicating science to lay audiences is an important skill for all scientists, particularly as they are called upon to demonstrate the value of public investment in research. It’s becoming increasingly important to engage the public in your research during the planning stages. Public communication is a world apart from writing manuscripts and conference posters, and it takes a lot of practice. Expect to have to trade your technical jargon for more common words, pull out the most essential and interesting elements of your work, and tailor your message to your audience.

    Most graduate students and many postdocs spend some time teaching. If you’re planning for a teaching-focused position at a four-year college, high school, or museum, for example, you will have to devote more time to this skill than your colleagues who are pursuing research-oriented positions. Even they would benefit from teaching experience if they’re bound for academia, however. 

    Mentoring is another key skill to cultivate. It’s especially important for those in teaching and advisory positions, and it’s good practice for anyone seeking a leadership or management role. To progress in your career, you’ll undoubtedly want to draw upon the support and guidance of others. If you’re not already comfortable reaching out to others for advice, you should look for opportunities to do this and to begin forging relationships with potential mentors.

    No matter what path you take, at some point you’ll have to navigate a difficult conversation. This might include asking for a promotion or raise, negotiating your start-up package, or resolving a dispute with a coworker. Skilled communicators can handle these conversations with confidence, grace, and diplomacy.   

    Management and leadership

    Whether you’re managing an academic research laboratory or running a company, if you’re supervising people, you need to know how to facilitate effective teamwork and manage day-to-day operations in an inclusive and equitable way. This includes being able to plan and organize projects—not just execute them; delegate responsibilities; provide instruction, guidance, and feedback to your team; and handle conflicts that arise between students or employees. While time management is an important skill for everyone, it’s especially important for managers who are balancing multiple projects and have a staff that relies on them for timely assistance and feedback. Moreover, good leaders don’t just supervise their employees; they create a vision and goals for their teams, motivate and inspire progress toward those goals, and serve as role models by demonstrating the behaviors that they want others to display, learn from, and pass on.

    Professionalism

    At a minimum, professionalism includes adhering to the rules and regulations of your workplace and demonstrating workplace etiquette. Acting professionally also means being a good colleague by fulfilling your commitments, meeting deadlines, and fostering positive relationships in the workplace. Professionalism extends beyond your laboratory or office and into your institution and discipline as well. It will be beneficial for your career to join institutional or professional society committees, participate in extracurricular departmental functions, and serve on editorial and advisory boards. These activities are a great way to network, gain experience, and demonstrate your commitment to your field, and they can be very important to your professional advancement.

    Responsible conduct of research

    Related to professionalism, responsible conduct of research encompasses the rules, regulations, and professional practices that apply to the practice of science. Careful record-keeping practices are paramount. Scientists should be able to replicate their work and provide sufficient information to others so that they can replicate it. They should be well-versed in data management and sharing standards, including relevant tools and repositories. Researchers must also adhere to the rules regulating research with humans and animals. Authorship is another component of responsible conduct of research. What contributions must one make to the project to be listed as an author? What determines authorship order? How should work by other scientists be cited to avoid plagiarism? In an era in which artificial intelligence (AI) tools are proliferating, what is the legitimate role of AI in research, including grant applications and publications? You should be able to identify and manage research misconduct and real or perceived conflicts of interest when you encounter them. Failure to manage these issues appropriately could have negative consequences, including damage to your reputation, poor performance evaluations, and even termination.

    Career development

    The last group of skills in the myIDP skills assessment is geared at helping you improve your ability to explore the career options available to you, make a positive impression on potential employers, and land the job that you want. You should take advantage of the many opportunities during your training to connect with other people, whether at department seminars, happy hours, or conferences. These people are part of your professional network; your interactions could spark a collaboration, tip you off to job opportunities, or introduce you to potential employers.

    Early in your training, you should start to become familiar with the career exploration resources available to you. These may include a career center at your university, graduate school, postdoc office, or library. myIDP also has an extensive collection of career resources. Investigate whether your scientific disciplinary society has useful resources, often found at their annual conference. Although you may not be ready to start applying for jobs, you should learn what you’ll need to do to create a competitive application and begin adding relevant experiences to your CV or resume. If you haven’t had practice interviewing or negotiating, you may want to read up on effective techniques or take a workshop or seminar.

    Using the myIDP self-assessment scale

    When using my IDP to conduct your self assessment, you’ll be asked to rate your proficiency in each skill and knowledge area on a scale of 1 through 5, where 1 is “highly deficient” (i.e., you do not have a skill) and 5 is “highly proficient.” As you rate each item, it will be most helpful if you use the full range of scores. Rating just a few items as a “1” will help distinguish the skills that need the most improvement if applicable to your work, and rating just a few items as a “5” will help discern the skills at which you are best. Although you might find it helpful to solicit input from your mentor, colleagues, or even family and friends, this scale is intended to be your own subjective assessment of whether your skills are appropriate for your level of training. As you rate yourself, you should think about how you compare to your peers. For example, if you are a first-year graduate student, it is expected that you will be less proficient in performing the technical skills required in your laboratory or writing scientific manuscripts than a senior student or postdoc would be.

    Next steps

    By using the myIDP skills assessment, you’ll be able to compare your skills to those relevant for various scientific career paths.  You’ll also have the opportunity to explore career resources associated with each of these paths and begin setting goals to acquire the skills you’ll need for that path. You’ll find that some of these skills can be honed in the context of your research or teaching responsibilities. Others may require you to take advantage of learning and professional opportunities outside the lab. While you have to stay focused on fulfilling your current research commitments, don’t forget to make some time to develop the breadth of skills you’ll need for the next phase of your career.


    1 A. Gammie, J. Lorsch, S. Singh. Catalyzing the Modernization of Graduate Education. https://loop.nigms.nih.gov/2015/11/catalyzing-the-modernization-of-graduate-education/

    2 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2018. Graduate STEM Education for the 21st Century. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25038

    3 P. Hitchcock et al.  The future of graduate and postdoctoral training in the biosciences.  eLife 6:e32715, 2017.

    4 Coalition of State Bioscience Institutes. 2023 Life Sciences Workforce Trends Report, June 2023.

    5 N.A. Henkhaus, C.B. Taylor, V.R. Greenlee, D.B. Sickler, D.B. Stern. Reinventing postgraduate training in the plant sciences: T-training defined through modularity, customization, and distributed mentorship. Plant Direct 2:1-12, 2018.

    6 National Postdoctoral Association 2009. The NPA Core Competencies.

    Read More

    https://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/sciencecareers_myidp_logo_16x9-vQ7tOW.png 877 1560 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-20 12:46:252026-11-20 12:46:25myIDP: Successful scientists need both technical and professional skills

    myIDP: Creating a career plan by you for you

    November 20, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    This is the first article in a series designed to help you create an Individual Development Plan (IDP) using myIDP, a web-based career-planning tool created to help graduate students and postdocs in the sciences define and pursue their career goals. To learn more about myIDP and begin the career exploration and planning process, please visit myidp.sciencecareers.org.
    This is an updated version of an article originally published in 2012.

    Juan is completing his Ph.D. in molecular biology. He has both enjoyed and been highly successful in graduate school, having received a competitive predoctoral research fellowship and published three first-author papers ­­in solid journals. However, when faced with determining the next step for his career, he feels uncertain and unprepared. Kruti is a second-year Ph.D. student in biomedical engineering. She has learned about many potential career options from an introductory class in her department and ongoing seminars at her university. She wants to start exploring her career options sooner rather than later but is unsure of how to get started. As a newly arrived postdoctoral fellow, Jacob is learning challenging new experimental techniques and getting to know members of his research group. He anticipates applying for fellowship grants and publishing in top journals, but he wants some help mapping out a set of steps to ensure his postdoctoral experience is structured, productive, and as brief as possible. What can Juan, Kruti, and Jacob do to feel more confident about taking charge of their career plans?

    Like the students and the postdoc in the examples above, you, as a scientist-in-training, will be working through a variety of challenges as you advance your training and professional development in pursuit of your career goals. Navigating toward your next professional steps is not easy! This process is complicated by the enormous array of careers available to Ph.D. scientists1 and made even more complex by fluxes in the job market, increasing numbers of Ph.D. scientists in the labor pool, inadequate career guidance, meager training in non-academic skills during Ph.D. training, and the fact that your own career-related priorities, interests, values, and skills may shift over time. Given these concerns, it’s not surprising that recent studies have highlighted the transitory nature of career goals during Ph.D. training2 and called for more support and structure to be provided for Ph.D. scientists when it comes to preparing for their careers.3  

    To help you apply additional structure to your career planning, we created myIDP, an interactive, web-based career-planning tool to guide you through a systematic process of creating an Individual Development Plan (IDP), with resources to help you identify career goals that are right for you and develop a step-by-step plan to help you reach those goals. This tool was first launched in 2011 and is based on the concept outlined in 2002 by the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology’s Individual Development Plan (IDP) for Postdoctoral Scholars4, 5, 6. Now, years after its release, the myIDP tool continues to be used both by individuals as a self-study tool and in coordination with career-planning workshops and mentorship meetings.

    Planning for success

    There is a body of literature that underscores the value of deliberate career planning. This research finds that people who develop and implement strategies to pursue career-specific goals achieve greater career success as measured by salary, promotions, and level of responsibility.7 They also report greater career satisfaction and rate themselves as more successful than their peers compared to those without career plans.8 A nationwide study of 7,600 postdoctoral researchers found that postdocs who developed training plans with their advisors at the start of their appointments reported greater satisfaction, published more papers, and experienced fewer conflicts with their advisors.9

    Getting started

    The literature demonstrates that an intentional IDP process includes multiple components, including reflecting on your own skills, values, and interests; exploring and evaluating career opportunities; setting specific goals to prepare you for the career paths to which you aspire; and prioritizing your goals. After discussing these goals and outlining strategies with mentors, it’s time to put the plan into place. Moving forward, you return periodically to the IDP process to reflect, explore, revise goals, and re-prioritize.

    myIDP is designed to help you with each of these steps. It includes exercises to guide you through the self-assessment process, and it will help you distinguish how your skills and interests might align with 20 categories of scientific careers. For each career path, there is an extensive list of resources in the form of articles, books, and professional organizations, which you can scrutinize to gain a better understanding of careers you are unfamiliar with. You can consider the breadth of individuals who provide you with mentorship. Finally, there is a tool to assist you in setting and achieving your goals. Throughout the process, you will be able to store your progress on the myIDP web portal—your information will be kept private, viewable only by you and those you wish to share it with—and you can request automated reminders to help you keep on top of your deadlines. As you move through the tool, access articles about each step for further guidance. Our goal is to help you demystify and streamline the IDP process so that you can more easily identify, attain, and succeed in a next career step that is right for you.

    Positive outcomes

    Studies have revealed that both mentees and mentors find IDPs beneficial. In a study conducted by FASEB10, a majority of postdocs who developed an IDP reported that it helped them assess their skills and abilities and identify the skills they would need to advance their careers. One respondent noted that it helped “not just to decide on a goal, but to have that goal in mind all the time.” Mentors reported observing similar benefits for their postdocs, and both groups found the IDP to be helpful for facilitating communication about postdocs’ career goals. According to one investigator, “The IDP helped me guide my postdocs toward experiences that would benefit their own career objectives. It allowed them to better tailor their experiences toward their career paths.” Similar outcomes have been found in the use of IDPs with Ph.D. students. One student noted that, “It helps you delineate your goals, ideas, and future plans in a straightforward, digestible format for discussion with mentors.”

    myIDP is a tool you can use to create a plan by you, for you. Get started now at https://myidp.sciencecareers.org/.


    1 NIH Biomedical Research Workforce Working Group Report (2012). https://acd.od.nih.gov/documents/reports/Biomedical_research_wgreport.pdf

    2 A.M. Brown et al. (2023). From goal to outcome: analyzing the career progression of biomedical sciences PhD careers in a longitudinal study using an expanded taxonomy. FASEB BioAdvances 00:1-26

    3 NIH Advisory Committee to the Director working group on re-envisioning NIH-supported postdoctoral training (2023). https://acd.od.nih.gov/documents/presentations/12152023_Postdoc_Working_Group_Report.pdf

    4 R.J. Preston RJ (2002). Mentors are made not born. The Scientist 16(17):54

    5 P.S. Clifford PS (2002). Quality time with your mentor. The Scientist 16(19):59

    6 H.I. Rieff HI (2002). A mentor maintenance program. The Scientist 16(20):65

    7 T.W.H. Ng, L.T. Eby, K.L. Sorensen, D.C. Feldman (2005). Predictors of objective and subjective career success: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology 58: 367-408.

    8 A.E. Abele, B.S. Wiese (2008). The nomological network of self-management strategies and career success. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 81:733-749.

    9 G. Davis (2005). Doctors without orders. American Scientist 93(3 supplement):1-13.

    10 J.A. Hobin, P.S. Clifford, B.M. Dunn, S Rich, L.B. Justement. Putting PhDs to work: career planning for today’s scientist. CBE Life Sciences 13:49-53, 2014.

    Read More

    https://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/sciencecareers_myidp_logo_16x9-XYB8B9.png 877 1560 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-20 12:46:212026-11-20 12:46:21myIDP: Creating a career plan by you for you

    I’m a professor, and I still need feedback

    November 19, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    I had barely settled into my new office as an assistant professor when I decided to submit my first research grant. I was excited to finally have the freedom to pursue my own ideas. But putting them forward in a major grant proposal felt daunting. So when I saw an opportunity to present my proposal at a luncheon chalk talk and get feedback from colleagues, I jumped at it. The questions began almost immediately after I started talking. One professor questioned an assumption behind an experiment. Someone else suggested I remove a research question entirely and replace it with a different one. Another asked whether I had enough evidence to justify part of my approach. The proposal I had spent weeks building was being taken apart in front of me, or so I felt. I left the room feeling overwhelmed.

    I had presented my science many times before. As a Ph.D. student and postdoc, I regularly gave lab meeting presentations, discussed data with mentors, and defended my interpretations in front of colleagues. I had learned to expect questions, sometimes difficult ones.

    But those discussions felt different. As a trainee, I was usually presenting experiments that belonged to a larger project. Even when I had substantial ownership, a mentor stood behind the work, and it was part of a broader scientific structure.

    This time there was no adviser; it was all me. And the room was filled with faculty members who had written and reviewed far more research grants than I had. I had expected helpful feedback. But I didn’t anticipate how deeply they would challenge nearly every part of the proposal. I spent the luncheon trying to answer their questions while also taking notes. At some point my pages seemed to contain more questions than answers.

    Afterward, I wondered whether I had exposed the proposal too early. Maybe I should have polished it more before showing it to others. More uncomfortably, I also wondered whether the questions had exposed my ignorance about things I should have known.

    But after my initial embarrassment faded, I opened my notes again. I started to go through the comments one by one, checking the literature to see whether I was on solid ground. Some comments made me reconsider assumptions I had not realized I was making. A few led me to change experiments or explain the rationale more carefully. Not every suggestion altered my research proposal, but almost every question forced me to think and communicate more clearly. I began to see that the questions themselves were part of the process of making the science more rigorous.

    I had assumed that as an independent investigator, I should increasingly have the answers myself and not need help from others. But the luncheon helped me see feedback differently. Regardless of where you are in your career, it can be tremendously helpful to put a developing proposal in front of colleagues early enough that their questions can still shape it. What once felt intimidating has now become an important part of how I strengthen my thinking, and I try not to take questions and suggestions personally.

    I have also come to realize I was lucky to get the chance to give the luncheon talk, and to have colleagues who genuinely want junior faculty to succeed and were willing to give their time. Not every early-career investigator works in an environment where there is a forum for sharing developing proposals and receiving thoughtful feedback from experienced colleagues—for instance, through a chalk talk, grant discussion group, or even an informal gathering. At a career stage when so much is new, from building a laboratory to managing people and competing for major grants, having a structure like this can make an enormous difference.

    Institutions can nurture the right culture, too. We often tell young investigators to seek mentorship and ask for feedback, but doing so is much easier at institutions where asking for help is expected rather than interpreted as a sign that someone is not ready to be independent.

    Do you have an interesting career story to share? You can find our author guidelines here.

    Read More

    https://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/20261119_wl-xMOdjS.jpg 804 1216 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-19 14:20:062026-11-19 14:20:06I’m a professor, and I still need feedback

    How an interdisciplinary research team taught me to lead with humility

    November 12, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    It was a nerve-wracking moment in my career. I had just received a grant to tackle a large interdisciplinary research project. Up to that point, I had mostly managed a small team of Ph.D. students in my own discipline, mining engineering. Now, I had to lead a group of 20 researchers from disparate fields and turn their knowledge into something we could put into practice. I assumed the best approach would be to make sure I understood every facet of the project, provide clear direction, and have answers when others were uncertain. But that approach led my team astray.

    Our first major decision came a few weeks into the project, when we had to agree on how to design a mining machine to break rock mechanically. I proposed its main structural layout largely from my experience, using mining concepts I knew well. In project meetings that included mechanical engineers, sensor experts, and others, I confidently introduced the design. When no one challenged it, I took that as a sign that we had agreed on a direction. We quickly moved on to discussions of how each group could contribute to building it.

    Months later, after we had produced the components and assembled the machine, some unexpected problems appeared. The arm at the back was so heavy that the supporting structure threatened to bend. The weight at the rear made the whole thing less stable. And when we tried to drive it, we found that turning the machine took much more space than we expected. There was no way it would work in deep underground tunnels.

    I called the team together to discuss how to fix the issues. At first, we talked about minor adjustments. But the more we talked, the more I realized the problem was my initial design. So, I asked my team a different question: If you could adjust the main layout, what would you change?

    That’s when we finally made progress. A structural expert suggested adding a support wheel. A mechanical engineer suggested adding a joint, so the machine could turn more effectively. They were both seeing the design from a perspective that I hadn’t been able to see myself. It took us more time, and came at a high cost, but we eventually found a way to fix the machine.

    Afterward, my team members told me they had noticed the flaws in the initial design much earlier, but they hadn’t dared to raise their concerns. I was the project leader, mining engineering was my field, and I had presented the design confidently, using specialist terms they were not familiar with.

    Reflecting on that experience, I began to see my role differently. I wanted to create an atmosphere in which people felt comfortable asking questions and sharing dissenting opinions. To encourage that, I began to model that kind of behavior myself. I went into meetings no longer trying to have an answer to every question. When I did not understand something, I said so and asked. I wanted the team to see that saying “I don’t know” was acceptable, even for the team leader.

    Gradually others began to do the same. Team members became more willing to challenge ideas and say when they did not understand a term or concept. They also started to explain complex ideas in more general language and think more carefully about whether colleagues from other fields could follow their reasoning. The discussions took longer, but previously hidden disagreements and questions became easier to see.

    Interdisciplinary work can be a powerful approach to research, because every discipline has its own blind spots, including mine. But it can be tricky to harness collective knowledge and ensure the team works smoothly. I have come to realize the best approach as a leader is to embrace humility and to make clear that all team members have a voice at the table. Ultimately, it’s not my job to see everything; my job is to help the team see what none of us could see alone.

    Do you have an interesting career story to share? You can find our author guidelines here.

    Read More

    http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png 0 0 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-12 20:09:312026-11-12 20:09:31How an interdisciplinary research team taught me to lead with humility

    Harvard grad students strike again, citing inadequate harassment protections

    November 6, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    For the second time this year, the Harvard Graduate Students Union has gone on strike after the university failed to provide a “meaningful response” to demands for better pay and stronger protections for survivors of harassment and noncitizen student workers. The first strike, which began on 21 April, lasted 40 days until the university agreed to begin new negotiations. But on 27 October, research assistants and teaching fellows walked away from their labs and classrooms once again following what the union said was a final unsuccessful bargaining session.

    “Many of us are really proud to study here,” says Ruth Tweedy, a striking Ph.D. candidate in earth and planetary sciences. Yet “being faced with some of the reality about how little empathy and compassion [the university is] showing for my fellow student workers has been really disheartening.”

    In response to Science’s request for comment, Harvard University pointed to a 26 October letter from administrators, posted online, that describes their proposal to the union. “[T]he University has shown an unwavering commitment to reaching an agreement” and “remains fully committed to continued good-faith negotiations,” the letter says.

    Harvard students aren’t alone in their discontent. Attacks on universities by President Donald Trump’s administration, the allegations of sexual assault at Cornell University, rising costs of living, and other concerns are roiling many campuses. Graduate student worker unions at universities including at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Brown University, and Columbia University are currently renegotiating their contracts, with MIT setting a strike deadline of 12 November.

    For a year and a half, the Harvard union, which represents 4000 students, has asked the university to establish third-party arbitration for harassment-related proceedings. It currently handles them internally, through the Title IX office, which administers the federal ban on sex discrimination in education. Unions at several other institutions, including the University of Michigan, MIT, and New York University, have negotiated such arrangements. But Harvard has refused, arguing that federal privacy laws prevent it from sharing Title IX information with third parties, the union says. Joseph van der Naald, a research fellow at the National Center for the Study of Collective Bargaining in Higher Education and the Professions at Hunter College, disagrees. Pursuing this demand “is completely legal,” he says.

    According to the union, one in five student workers at Harvard reports experiencing harassment, discrimination, or bullying. When cases are reported, the university can take years or even decades to resolve them, the students say.

    Among the standard-bearers on this issue is Claire Traweek, a graduate student in mechanical engineering who says she left her laboratory after experiencing harassment. As she has described in rallies over the past week, some of Traweek’s men colleagues made sexist comments, called women “birds,” and expressed preferences based on women’s physical attributes, among other offenses. For more than a year, Traweek tried to file a formal complaint with Harvard’s Title IX office, without success; emails Science has seen show staff were often slow to respond. “It feels like Harvard’s number one mission is to make the least work possible for themselves and make the complainants go away,” says Traweek, who eventually found a home in a new lab. Harvard did not respond to questions about her case.

    Another major topic at issue is compensation, a sore point at institutions across the country. Current salaries for Harvard’s unionized student workers—ranging from $26,000 to $50,000 per year—are well below the living wage estimate of $67,513 for an individual in that region. The union wants the range to increase to $45,000 to $55,000, plus raises or annual cost-of-living adjustments. The union also seeks guaranteed funding so research assistants experiencing sexual harassment or bullying can transition to a new lab without a gap in income. According to the union, Harvard rejected cost-of-living protections and offered to raise its lowest salaries from $26,000 to $31,362 by 2030.

    The union’s third demand concerns protecting noncitizen student workers, who have been targeted at universities including Columbia, where federal agents searched student rooms, arrested a student, revoked a student’s visa, and entered a residential building without a warrant. The union wants Harvard to secure sensitive immigration documents, provide pay during visa delays or detention, notify students when U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents enter campus, and require judicial warrants before allowing agents access. Harvard has rejected these proposals.

    According to van der Naald, a union contract cannot require a university to violate laws requiring it to disclose immigration information to the authorities. But the university could commit to notifying students of ICE’s presence and not sharing personal information without a judicial warrant.

    A heated bargaining session on 5 November ended when Harvard officials walked out in the middle of a sexual harassment discussion, according to the union, suggesting the strike is unlikely to end soon. 

    Read More

    http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png 0 0 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-06 16:02:012026-11-06 16:02:01Harvard grad students strike again, citing inadequate harassment protections

    Life felt dark as an international researcher in the U.S., but I’m finding breaks in the clouds

    November 5, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    My Ph.D. years were, for the most part, enjoyable. I was making progress toward becoming an academic, my career goal for as long as I could remember. I deeply missed my loved ones back in Iran whom I had not seen since I left for graduate studies in the United States. But my workdays felt mostly sunny, interrupted by the occasional overcast—until near the end of my program, when shifts in U.S. policy brought funding cuts, fewer positions, restrictions on immigration, and growing hostility toward international students like me. Dark clouds were gathering over the future I had imagined.

    I was fortunate to find a wonderful postdoctoral position, a ray of sunshine I needed. But another cloud loomed when people in my home country calling for change faced a wave of violence and repression. An internet shutdown followed, cutting off communication as families feared for their loved ones. For weeks, I didn’t know how mine were doing. Eventually we managed to speak by phone; they were safe. But that didn’t erase the horror of what had happened, or the helplessness of watching it unfold from across the world. Soon after came military conflict with the U.S. I was constantly asking myself, are my loved ones alive? Will I see them again?

    While fearing for those back home, I was also trying to hold on to my own future. The U.S. government paused processing certain immigration applications solely based on country of birth, putting my employment at risk. Suddenly, I didn’t know how much time I would have to work on my postdoctoral projects, let alone whether I would be able to stay long enough to pursue the academic career I dreamed of.

    I had always thought of myself as an optimistic person. But so much had happened in such a short time. The rhetoric around immigration and visa policies made me feel increasingly unwelcome in the country I had come to love, where I was trying to build a life. I started to question the years I had invested in building a career in the U.S., when it could suddenly and arbitrarily be taken away.

    I couldn’t enjoy my days anymore, or concentrate on my work. I consumed news constantly, searching for some encouraging sign. Instead, every development seemed to give me something new to worry about. Making matters worse, I felt I couldn’t talk about it with the people around me, as many of them lived under completely different circumstances. To them, things that could determine whether I would be able to stay in the country, continue my career, or see my family again were, understandably, distant abstractions.

    Eventually, I realized worrying wouldn’t solve anything. I started to journal, trying to remember the blessings I had. I forced myself to put aside worries until a designated evening “worry time.” And I returned to an old friend: Persian poetry. There I found centuries of human experience—the same fears and struggles recurring across time, and the hope and love that helped the writers endure. My condition was not new and I was not alone.

    The poetry reminded me, too, that life is short and struggles are temporary. Before it was too late, I needed to return to the pursuits I had loved long before any of this happened: doing science and creative work, discovering unfamiliar ideas, and meeting people who see the world differently from me. I broke my silence about my struggles, opening up to the people around me. My Ph.D. and postdoctoral advisers listened and shared, and I realized they have their own clouds, too.

    There are some bright spots, such as a recent court ruling that certain immigration restrictions are arbitrary and capricious and need to be stopped, and voters taking decisive action in the midterm elections. But I’m no longer waiting for all of the uncertainties to disappear before I allow myself to enjoy my work, my life, or an ordinary day. As it happens, partly cloudy has always been my favorite weather.

    Do you have an interesting career story to share? You can find our author guidelines here.

    Read More

    https://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/20261105_wl-KlWmcQ.jpg 804 1216 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-05 14:17:522026-11-05 14:17:52Life felt dark as an international researcher in the U.S., but I’m finding breaks in the clouds

    For early-career scientists, the cost of AI can be a problem

    November 3, 2026/0 Comments/in From ScienceMag: Careers Articles/by Vincent Barbier

    From ScienceMag:

    Earlier this year, Saad Bhamla, who leads a biophysics and engineering lab at the University of Colorado Boulder, sent a poll to the nearly 2 dozen members of his lab: Which artificial intelligence (AI) tools were they using? How much were they paying?

    The answers caught him by surprise. “I realized, holy moly, everybody’s paying anywhere from $20 to … $200” per month, Bhamla says. “I was like: ‘This is a tax.’”

    It’s not a unique situation. As AI gets better at the work involved in science, more scientists see it as essential rather than a nice to have. But researchers tell Science access to the best tools today depends less on need than on who can pay—and that the costs of AI are falling especially hard on early-career scientists, many of whom are reluctant to raise the issue because it feels taboo.

    In a survey of more than 10,000 researchers around the world, carried out in March by Nature, 41% said they paid for their main AI tool themselves, compared with just 11% who said their institutions covered the fees. Those who relied most heavily on AI to do their research were more likely to be paying out of their own pockets, and heavy AI users were also disproportionately early in their careers.

    Some universities have struck campuswide deals with AI firms. And companies such as OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google also have programs to give tens of thousands of scientists free or reduced-price access to their tools. But the versions universities make available to students are often too limited for heavy coding or data analysis, and it’s unclear how long any giveaways from the companies will last. 

    In Bhamla’s case, the results of his poll caused him to ask his university whether it could cover his lab’s bills. No, he was told, because it already gives students and faculty access to tools, including ChatGPT Edu. Ultimately, Bhamla decided to cover the costs of the AI his team says it needs out of his own funding, costing thousands of dollars a year.

    Elsewhere, many graduate students are shouldering the costs themselves. Haris Riaz, a Ph.D. student in his final year at the University of Arizona, says he often pays $300 or more per month for Anthropic’s Claude Code and ChatGPT’s Codex, especially during crunch periods ahead of a deadline. For Riaz, who studies how large language models (LLMs) absorb knowledge, “all aspects of the research process … basically involve heavy usage of AI tools.” His university does provide access to LLMs, but it doesn’t offer the most up-to-date models and it doesn’t include agents—models that carry out multistep tasks on their own, such as writing and running code.

    Riaz says he’s “lucky” that industry internships have helped him cover some costs; if he had to depend on his stipend alone, it would have been a “significant hit.” Yet he’s steadfast in his belief he needs the latest tools. “There’s no middle ground. It’s either you spend the money … or you work on some very small old problems.” 

    Omar Choudhry, a Ph.D. student at the University of Leeds using AI for medical diagnosis and care, was able to cancel a personal subscription to Claude after his lab joined Anthropic’s discounted plan for scientists. It gives a research group up to 25 seats that are free, or priced at $15 per month for higher usage. Because Choudhry’s lab has fewer than 25 people, he says members realized they could each use several seats. He still has to pay the $15 for each seat he takes himself, but it’s a better deal than he had before. Still, he doesn’t expect the discounts to last—and he also pays $200 per month out of pocket for ChatGPT. “We all know that this is just temporary,” Choudhry says. “Eventually, all these prices go up.”

    Support from institutions can also be fragile. Jeffrey Backus spends much of his day chatting with Claude or ChatGPT—he has subscriptions to both. He’s in the fourth year of a theoretical particle physics Ph.D. at Princeton University but works mostly from the nearby Institute for Advanced Study (IAS). Backus paid for his own $20-per-month ChatGPT subscription, but IAS covered his heftier $200-per-month Claude plan during a 3-month, computationally heavy project. That support didn’t continue, however, and he now pays for Claude himself. “This is so essential right now to what I’m doing that I would definitely fork over the money for sure,” Backus says.

    (Princeton does offer more advanced AI tools to graduate students if a faculty member sponsors them, according to the university’s website. The university did not respond to a request to clarify who pays.)

    Sometimes, the early-career researchers most likely to fall through the gaps are those least willing to say so. “AI usage is looked down upon,” says another Princeton Ph.D. student who asked to remain anonymous. “There’s a level of embarrassment, I’ve noticed at least, when people admit to having used AI for whatever research product they’re showing.”

    The cost of accessing tools and “tokens”—the basic unit of AI computing power—raises questions about whether fees are shaping who gets ahead, says Igor Chirikov, a researcher at the University of California, Berkeley who runs an annual survey of students at research universities. The person “who has access to those tokens will probably be a better scholar,” he says, “as opposed to, if you’re a smart person, you’ll be a better scholar.”

    In nations where funding is scarcer, the AI divide can be especially stark. Giovani de Almeida Valdrighi is a computer science Ph.D. student at the State University of Campinas who studies fairness in machine learning algorithms. He pays about $20 per month for Claude. Valdrighi says he can afford it only because the stipend he receives through his scholarship is “one of the highest” in Brazil. But for a student on the standard federal doctoral stipend of 3100 reais per month ($615) the same plan would consume about 3.5% of their income, and many of his friends go without.

    Top-tier tools are further out of reach. Ana Clara Zoppi Serpa, a Ph.D. student living in Belo Horizonte, Brazil, who tests LLM safety, pays $10 per month for a cheaper service that gives her access to several models, topping up with credits when she hits her limit. “I would love to have a subscription of Kimi or Claude, but I end up finding them more expensive,” she says. At $200 per month, a top-tier plan is “almost the price of the monthly rent of a small apartment” near the university, she says. She could afford it, but isn’t willing to. And others, she notes, “can’t afford that, so it’s not accessible.”

    For a long time, Valdrighi says he used Google’s free AI tools but switched to paid tools when he saw peers with better models moving faster. “I did not decide to start paying because I like the idea of the product,” he says. “It was more because of the pressure that everyone is using it, and you have to use it also.”

    On an internship in Germany this year, Valdrighi was surprised to find students paying for their own subscriptions as a matter of course. “I was shocked when I saw this difference,” he says. “I believe that’s kind of unfair because the research becomes pay to win.” Labs in different countries have always had unequal equipment, he notes. “But the difference, I believe, is that the university is paying for this equipment, while with AI, actually it’s the researchers that are paying.”

    Valdrighi isn’t alone in his unease. Several researchers whose access to AI is largely paid for by others told Science they worry about colleagues slipping through the cracks, whether down the corridor or overseas. “I’m very advantaged,” Backus acknowledges. “But it does really bother me.”

    For Bhamla, the solution starts with having open conversations about AI’s costs. His lab now has an AI tools channel on Slack, and one researcher has even made an AI bot to answer questions team members have. “We are openly discussing and embracing becoming ‘AI-native,’” Bhamla says. In many cases, however, he thinks the relationships between faculty members and their students is a bit like those parents have with their kids. When it comes to AI, he says, “the parents are a little bit out of touch with what the kids are doing.”

    Science’s AI in Science reporting initiative is supported by Ray Rothrock & family.

    Read More

    https://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/20261023_aicost_on-PqalFK.jpg 804 1216 Vincent Barbier http://postdocinusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Logo-PostdocInUSA-300x165.png Vincent Barbier2026-11-03 17:06:282026-11-03 17:06:28For early-career scientists, the cost of AI can be a problem
    Page 1 of 24123›»

    Follow us on Facebook

    Posts Categories

    • American traditions
    • Career Guide for PhDs & Postdocs
    • From ScienceMag: Careers Articles
    • Nature Careers Podcast
    • News
    • Postdoc Interview Series
    • Postdoctoral Experience
    • Scientific Writing
    • US National Holidays explained

    Latest News

    • myIDP: Applying your self-assessment results to career decision-makingNovember 20, 2026 - 12:46 pm
    • myIDP: InterestsNovember 20, 2026 - 12:46 pm
    • myIDP: What do you care about?November 20, 2026 - 12:46 pm
    • myIDP: Successful scientists need both technical and professional skillsNovember 20, 2026 - 12:46 pm
    • myIDP: Creating a career plan by you for youNovember 20, 2026 - 12:46 pm

    Science Shop Products

    • The Doctor Canvas Print The Doctor Canvas Print 12,00 $ – 42,00 $Price range: 12,00 $ through 42,00 $
    • THC Necklace THC Necklace
      Rated 5.00 out of 5
      18,00 $
    • 0-931b54.jpeg Erlenmeyer Flask Necklace 22,00 $
    • Adrenaline Necklace Adrenaline Necklace 18,00 $ – 26,00 $Price range: 18,00 $ through 26,00 $
    • Heart Necklace Heart Necklace 28,00 $

    Looking for something…

    Search Search

    My DocPoints Balance

    Login to view your balance.

    © Copyright 2021 - PostdocInUSA
    • Link to Mail
    • Link to Facebook
    • Link to LinkedIn
    • Link to Youtube
    • Home
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Shipping Policy
    • Return & Refund Policy
    Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top

    PostdocInUSA website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

    OKLearn More

    Cookie and Privacy Settings



    How we use cookies

    We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

    Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

    Essential Website Cookies

    These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

    Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refusing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

    We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

    We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

    Google Analytics Cookies

    These cookies collect information that is used either in aggregate form to help us understand how our website is being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customize our website and application for you in order to enhance your experience.

    If you do not want that we track your visit to our site you can disable tracking in your browser here:

    Other external services

    We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

    Google Webfont Settings:

    Google Map Settings:

    Google reCaptcha Settings:

    Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

    Other cookies

    The following cookies are also needed - You can choose if you want to allow them:

    Privacy Policy

    You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

    Privacy Policy
    Accept settingsHide notification only