myIDP: Successful scientists need both technical and professional skills
From ScienceMag:
You have been expending a tremendous amount of effort in building the research and technical skills that are necessary for success in research. You may not have given much thought to other skills that you will need for a productive and satisfying career. The importance of professional skills is often underappreciated despite the fact that numerous professional organizations have emphasized the value of professional skills for Ph.D. scientists.
The National Institute of General Medical Sciences highlighted the range of skills needed to be a great scientist—from methods, technology, and quantitative skills to leadership, management, communication, and teamwork1. In their publication Graduate STEM Education for the 21st Century, the National Academy of Sciences called for training Ph.D. scientists in professional competencies like leadership, communication, and project management2. Likewise, a conference on the future of graduate and postdoctoral training in the biosciences advocating modernization of Ph.D. curricula to include skills in communication, teamwork and collaboration, leadership and development, and project management3. It is noteworthy that job postings by biotech employers also emphasize these skills.4 To help visualize a balance of research skills with professional skills, the construct of T-shaped professionals may be useful (Figure 1)5.

Successful Ph.D. scientists need deep knowledge in their area of disciplinary specialization as well as a breadth of professional skills.
Taking stock of your skills
The first step in honing your skill set is figuring out what you’re good at and what needs to be improved. While this may seem obvious, few of us really take the time to reflect on this. The myIDP skills assessment was designed to do just that. Created specifically for scientists, this assessment includes the knowledge, skills, and abilities that are important for success in research training as well as across a breadth of scientific careers. It is also designed to help scientists evaluate their competence in areas that may not have been a formal part of doctoral science training but are fundamental to obtaining—and keeping—science-related jobs. Adapted from the National Postdoctoral Association’s The NPA Postdoctoral Core Competencies6, the myIDP skills assessment has seven categories: scientific knowledge, research skills, communication, leadership and management, professionalism, responsible conduct of research, and career development. These skill areas are described in more detail below.
Scientific knowledge
To succeed in any discipline, you need to have the content knowledge. For scientists, this means having both a broad–based knowledge of science and a deep knowledge of their specific research area. Of course, science is dynamic; the knowledge base is changing daily as researchers collect more and more data. To be competitive, therefore, you should be able to critically evaluate the scientific literature, integrate new information about your field into your existing knowledge base, and identify gaps in the research that are ripe for new investigation.
Research skills
Whether you work at the bench or in the field, you must have the research and technical skills required to execute your studies. Over the course of your doctoral training, you should become increasingly proficient in study design, conducting the appropriate statistical analyses of your data, and interpreting the results. Throughout your scientific career, you’ll face intellectual and technical challenges that will call upon your ability to think creatively and propose innovative solutions to the problems you face, skills that will likely improve with practice. Publications are the coin of the realm in science, so, in addition to doing great work, you have to publish it. You should become familiar with the publishing standards in your discipline, acquire practice writing and submitting papers for publication, and take advantage of opportunities to serve as a reviewer.
Communication
By the time you get to graduate school, you should have mastered basic writing, editing, speaking, and presentation skills; if you haven’t, this should be a major focus of your skills development, as communication skills are highly valued in all careers. If you’re pursuing a research career, you should aim for expertise in writing scientific publications and grant proposals and giving technical talks and poster presentations. These skills are less important outside of research, but you’ll still need to be at least moderately proficient in these areas to complete graduate and postdoctoral work and to compete for some research administration roles.
Communicating science to lay audiences is an important skill for all scientists, particularly as they are called upon to demonstrate the value of public investment in research. It’s becoming increasingly important to engage the public in your research during the planning stages. Public communication is a world apart from writing manuscripts and conference posters, and it takes a lot of practice. Expect to have to trade your technical jargon for more common words, pull out the most essential and interesting elements of your work, and tailor your message to your audience.
Most graduate students and many postdocs spend some time teaching. If you’re planning for a teaching-focused position at a four-year college, high school, or museum, for example, you will have to devote more time to this skill than your colleagues who are pursuing research-oriented positions. Even they would benefit from teaching experience if they’re bound for academia, however.
Mentoring is another key skill to cultivate. It’s especially important for those in teaching and advisory positions, and it’s good practice for anyone seeking a leadership or management role. To progress in your career, you’ll undoubtedly want to draw upon the support and guidance of others. If you’re not already comfortable reaching out to others for advice, you should look for opportunities to do this and to begin forging relationships with potential mentors.
No matter what path you take, at some point you’ll have to navigate a difficult conversation. This might include asking for a promotion or raise, negotiating your start-up package, or resolving a dispute with a coworker. Skilled communicators can handle these conversations with confidence, grace, and diplomacy.
Management and leadership
Whether you’re managing an academic research laboratory or running a company, if you’re supervising people, you need to know how to facilitate effective teamwork and manage day-to-day operations in an inclusive and equitable way. This includes being able to plan and organize projects—not just execute them; delegate responsibilities; provide instruction, guidance, and feedback to your team; and handle conflicts that arise between students or employees. While time management is an important skill for everyone, it’s especially important for managers who are balancing multiple projects and have a staff that relies on them for timely assistance and feedback. Moreover, good leaders don’t just supervise their employees; they create a vision and goals for their teams, motivate and inspire progress toward those goals, and serve as role models by demonstrating the behaviors that they want others to display, learn from, and pass on.
Professionalism
At a minimum, professionalism includes adhering to the rules and regulations of your workplace and demonstrating workplace etiquette. Acting professionally also means being a good colleague by fulfilling your commitments, meeting deadlines, and fostering positive relationships in the workplace. Professionalism extends beyond your laboratory or office and into your institution and discipline as well. It will be beneficial for your career to join institutional or professional society committees, participate in extracurricular departmental functions, and serve on editorial and advisory boards. These activities are a great way to network, gain experience, and demonstrate your commitment to your field, and they can be very important to your professional advancement.
Responsible conduct of research
Related to professionalism, responsible conduct of research encompasses the rules, regulations, and professional practices that apply to the practice of science. Careful record-keeping practices are paramount. Scientists should be able to replicate their work and provide sufficient information to others so that they can replicate it. They should be well-versed in data management and sharing standards, including relevant tools and repositories. Researchers must also adhere to the rules regulating research with humans and animals. Authorship is another component of responsible conduct of research. What contributions must one make to the project to be listed as an author? What determines authorship order? How should work by other scientists be cited to avoid plagiarism? In an era in which artificial intelligence (AI) tools are proliferating, what is the legitimate role of AI in research, including grant applications and publications? You should be able to identify and manage research misconduct and real or perceived conflicts of interest when you encounter them. Failure to manage these issues appropriately could have negative consequences, including damage to your reputation, poor performance evaluations, and even termination.
Career development
The last group of skills in the myIDP skills assessment is geared at helping you improve your ability to explore the career options available to you, make a positive impression on potential employers, and land the job that you want. You should take advantage of the many opportunities during your training to connect with other people, whether at department seminars, happy hours, or conferences. These people are part of your professional network; your interactions could spark a collaboration, tip you off to job opportunities, or introduce you to potential employers.
Early in your training, you should start to become familiar with the career exploration resources available to you. These may include a career center at your university, graduate school, postdoc office, or library. myIDP also has an extensive collection of career resources. Investigate whether your scientific disciplinary society has useful resources, often found at their annual conference. Although you may not be ready to start applying for jobs, you should learn what you’ll need to do to create a competitive application and begin adding relevant experiences to your CV or resume. If you haven’t had practice interviewing or negotiating, you may want to read up on effective techniques or take a workshop or seminar.
Using the myIDP self-assessment scale
When using my IDP to conduct your self assessment, you’ll be asked to rate your proficiency in each skill and knowledge area on a scale of 1 through 5, where 1 is “highly deficient” (i.e., you do not have a skill) and 5 is “highly proficient.” As you rate each item, it will be most helpful if you use the full range of scores. Rating just a few items as a “1” will help distinguish the skills that need the most improvement if applicable to your work, and rating just a few items as a “5” will help discern the skills at which you are best. Although you might find it helpful to solicit input from your mentor, colleagues, or even family and friends, this scale is intended to be your own subjective assessment of whether your skills are appropriate for your level of training. As you rate yourself, you should think about how you compare to your peers. For example, if you are a first-year graduate student, it is expected that you will be less proficient in performing the technical skills required in your laboratory or writing scientific manuscripts than a senior student or postdoc would be.
Next steps
By using the myIDP skills assessment, you’ll be able to compare your skills to those relevant for various scientific career paths. You’ll also have the opportunity to explore career resources associated with each of these paths and begin setting goals to acquire the skills you’ll need for that path. You’ll find that some of these skills can be honed in the context of your research or teaching responsibilities. Others may require you to take advantage of learning and professional opportunities outside the lab. While you have to stay focused on fulfilling your current research commitments, don’t forget to make some time to develop the breadth of skills you’ll need for the next phase of your career.
1 A. Gammie, J. Lorsch, S. Singh. Catalyzing the Modernization of Graduate Education. https://loop.nigms.nih.gov/2015/11/catalyzing-the-modernization-of-graduate-education/
2 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2018. Graduate STEM Education for the 21st Century. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25038
3 P. Hitchcock et al. The future of graduate and postdoctoral training in the biosciences. eLife 6:e32715, 2017.
4 Coalition of State Bioscience Institutes. 2023 Life Sciences Workforce Trends Report, June 2023.
5 N.A. Henkhaus, C.B. Taylor, V.R. Greenlee, D.B. Sickler, D.B. Stern. Reinventing postgraduate training in the plant sciences: T-training defined through modularity, customization, and distributed mentorship. Plant Direct 2:1-12, 2018.
6 National Postdoctoral Association 2009. The NPA Core Competencies.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!