I’m a professor, and I still need feedback
From ScienceMag:
I had barely settled into my new office as an assistant professor when I decided to submit my first research grant. I was excited to finally have the freedom to pursue my own ideas. But putting them forward in a major grant proposal felt daunting. So when I saw an opportunity to present my proposal at a luncheon chalk talk and get feedback from colleagues, I jumped at it. The questions began almost immediately after I started talking. One professor questioned an assumption behind an experiment. Someone else suggested I remove a research question entirely and replace it with a different one. Another asked whether I had enough evidence to justify part of my approach. The proposal I had spent weeks building was being taken apart in front of me, or so I felt. I left the room feeling overwhelmed.
I had presented my science many times before. As a Ph.D. student and postdoc, I regularly gave lab meeting presentations, discussed data with mentors, and defended my interpretations in front of colleagues. I had learned to expect questions, sometimes difficult ones.
But those discussions felt different. As a trainee, I was usually presenting experiments that belonged to a larger project. Even when I had substantial ownership, a mentor stood behind the work, and it was part of a broader scientific structure.
This time there was no adviser; it was all me. And the room was filled with faculty members who had written and reviewed far more research grants than I had. I had expected helpful feedback. But I didn’t anticipate how deeply they would challenge nearly every part of the proposal. I spent the luncheon trying to answer their questions while also taking notes. At some point my pages seemed to contain more questions than answers.
Afterward, I wondered whether I had exposed the proposal too early. Maybe I should have polished it more before showing it to others. More uncomfortably, I also wondered whether the questions had exposed my ignorance about things I should have known.
But after my initial embarrassment faded, I opened my notes again. I started to go through the comments one by one, checking the literature to see whether I was on solid ground. Some comments made me reconsider assumptions I had not realized I was making. A few led me to change experiments or explain the rationale more carefully. Not every suggestion altered my research proposal, but almost every question forced me to think and communicate more clearly. I began to see that the questions themselves were part of the process of making the science more rigorous.
I had assumed that as an independent investigator, I should increasingly have the answers myself and not need help from others. But the luncheon helped me see feedback differently. Regardless of where you are in your career, it can be tremendously helpful to put a developing proposal in front of colleagues early enough that their questions can still shape it. What once felt intimidating has now become an important part of how I strengthen my thinking, and I try not to take questions and suggestions personally.
I have also come to realize I was lucky to get the chance to give the luncheon talk, and to have colleagues who genuinely want junior faculty to succeed and were willing to give their time. Not every early-career investigator works in an environment where there is a forum for sharing developing proposals and receiving thoughtful feedback from experienced colleagues—for instance, through a chalk talk, grant discussion group, or even an informal gathering. At a career stage when so much is new, from building a laboratory to managing people and competing for major grants, having a structure like this can make an enormous difference.
Institutions can nurture the right culture, too. We often tell young investigators to seek mentorship and ask for feedback, but doing so is much easier at institutions where asking for help is expected rather than interpreted as a sign that someone is not ready to be independent.


Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!